Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutAGENDA REPORT 2022 0601 CCSA REG ITEM 09A SUPPLEMENTAL MOORPARK CITY COUNCIL SUPPLEMENTAL AGENDA REPORT TO: Honorable City Council FROM: Jeremy Laurentowski, Parks and Recreation Director BY: Jessica Sandifer, Community Services Manager DATE: 06/01/2022 Regular Meeting SUBJECT: Consider Design of New Moorpark City Library CORRESPONDENCE RECEIVED Subsequent to the publication of the staff report, the attached correspondence was received from members of the public. Attachment Item: 9.A. SUPPLEMENTAL 1 Jessica Sandifer From:Mark Di Cecco <mark@diceccoarch.com> Sent:Wednesday, June 01, 2022 3:14 PM To:Jeremy Laurentowski Cc:Jessica Sandifer; Douglas Spondello; Carlene Saxton Subject:Comments on the two alternate new Library styles. Hi Jeremy,  As discussed, here are some comments on the new Library:  Industrial Style (preferred)  I agree with staff (you) that this version will be more more sustainable and maintenance friendly.   It also has slightly more civic presence.  The sustainability aspect should not be overlooked, and can set an example of what we want to see as a city.  some design comments to consider if this style moves forward:  There needs to be a break in the cornice at the entry to visually identify this as the entry point.   The cornice at the entry should be taller, and project forward slightly to be in a different wall plane   than the balance of the building. As an alternate, lowering the cornice everywhere but the entry would work too.  The lower shade structure with the tie backs looks great.  The canopy at the entry should not have the same detailing,   but extend out farther creating a larger overhang and be held up with columns like the rear of the building.  The columns (front and rear) should be wide flange steel to add to the industrial look.  The size and texture and mortar installation of the brick will be really important.  It is unclear what the stairs to the entry porch look like based on the renderings,   the low wall in the garden front hides them. The wall itself I think is really appropriate,   but maybe the steps need to be more identifiable in this public building.   The matching stone at the base of the building is appropriate too.  The window muntins and doors in the front elevation storefront should all line up to create a horizontal line.  This building form is simple and efficient enough that more of the budget   can be used to make the materials and interiors nicer for the library users.  Agrarian Style (not preferred)  Although not my choice, you know where the entry is.  The windows and views on the north at the stacks will be pretty stunning.  The building elements are not truly agrarian enough.  If the building wants to appear as an adaptive reuse of a barn, the roof pitch is too low.  The beams and ties are too stylized to appear as real elements.  There is a residential feel to this scheme more than an agrarian feel.   Is that appropriate for a civic building?   Not to be demeaning in any way, but this would make a great church in Palos Verdes.  Washing the windows will be problematic.   Having that much glazing on the south side of the building,   it will will be hard to control sunlight and will cause long term damage to the books.   The signage font (in either style) is not appropriate for a civic building like this.  ATTACHMENT 2   Whatever style is chosen will have a lot to do with what the Civic Center itself will look like.  What do we want our civic buildings to be?    Thanks very much, mark Dr. Mark Di Cecco AIA NCARB, LEED AP     Moorpark Resident? What do you like about each design? Is there anything you would change about the designs? Do you think these designs are appropriate for High Street? Do you have any other comments about the styles to share with us? 1 Yes The natural light that comes in from both options. Color of the brick/exterior walls of the industrial design. I'd prefer a white building with black accents and a unique Moorpark Library sign. Yes. Everyone thinks High Street has a "look", but I don't. Just get this project done. I'm surprised your survey doesn't ask for a preference on design choice. 2 Yes I like the one that is not so square, it has more life to it. Not so square. Yes Make it like the T.O. Library with a large childrens section and a fish tank and coffee shop 3 Yes I like the rustic one but I am worried that the windows might need alot of cleaning up top, or might let into much sun. I think the industrial design does not look inviting or home like. A library should feel very welcoming and comfortable. Yes the first one, not the industrial. It would be great if the library had a park adjoining. I would like to see more natural materials… stone, wood and things native to Moorpark. 4 Yes I like the Agrarian Inspired Design due to the big windows and warm welcome feel. I like the more modern design to spruce up high street. I did not like the industrial one as it reminded me of a school and too industrial for the area. High street needs something that anchors it. What better way than a beautiful modern library Modernize high street with the Agrarian Inspired Design 5 Yes I don’t like the industrial one. Is boring, looks like a cookie cutter elementary school and has no charm or personality. Ditch the industrial design The ag one yes, High Street should have buildings with character, not dull ugly buildings. 6 Yes I prefer the Agrarian style renderings over the industrial as Moorpark was not known for being an industrial town and I don’t think that particular style would blend in well with the rest of High Street. Moorpark has worked hard over the years to ensure the charm that High Street has to offer remains for years to come, and the industrial renderings I feel personally stray away from all of the work done so far. From my perspective, the Agrarian renderings have a much different feel in comparison to the real-world photos. The photos provided are very much what you think of a barn, with the red one looking similar to the Santa Paula train depot. I like how the renderings don’t look like traditional “barn wood†and more true natural wood tones. Wood tones can be difficult and we need something that is warm and welcoming, but won’t be go out of trend in just a few years. I think there can be a good compromise between paying homepage to the agricultural roots of our town, using natural/native products, yet looking like something that is high-end. Yes, I do, but more so one over the other. While I understand that Moorpark as a town is trying to grow and last long into the future, I think it would be appropriate to incorporate something within the library that recognizes Moorpark’s agricultural roots through photos and a small write-up. Moorpark Resident? What do you like about each design? Is there anything you would change about the designs? Do you think these designs are appropriate for High Street? Do you have any other comments about the styles to share with us? 7 Yes Modern designs No Yes 8 Yes I prefer the agrarian style as it seems warmer and more inviting. Yes 9 Yes 10 Yes I love the Agrarian design! The large windows and country vibe are well suited to our farm land suburbia. More windows if possible. Yes I think it would lovely and fit in well. No 11 Yes Love a big new library! It's hard to tell but I'm hoping that there is a lot of natural light coming in from every direction. Yes Lots of trees around the building would also be nice. 12 Yes Can’t really tell from the outside pictures. The landscaping surrounding does not look appealing. Need some beautiful nature around. Not sure need to see more detail pictures. It should embrace the diversity of MOORPARK. All ethnic backgrounds should be included. TO library is an excellent model to follow but can even be better. A place that May look like the City hall of Fillmore. A fountain outside to take beautiful wedding or any kind of special event pictures. A place that becomes the signature stop for families. 13 Yes I like that it means we might actually be getting closer to having a new library. The Agri one looks more like a shopping center to me, but it is a lot better than the brick prison building looking one. I'm not 100% excited about either one, but the Agri building fits in better with High Street. They need some work to make them more inviting. 14 Yes I prefer agrarian due to more windows for natural light. Yes 15 Yes Patio No Yes No 16 Yes Agrarian - I appreciate that it uses local materials and pays homage to Moorpark and Ventura Counties agricultural history. Industrial - This is my aesthetic preference and I believe it will flow more with the design proposed for High Street project. I would include larger covered outdoor opportunities and gathering areas. With our temperate weather, I wish more places used outdoor spaces. I think both are appropriate and would be an asset to the downtown area. Moorpark Resident? What do you like about each design? Is there anything you would change about the designs? Do you think these designs are appropriate for High Street? Do you have any other comments about the styles to share with us? 17 Yes I especially like the agrarian design because it looks welcoming. The industrial design looks to cold. I like all the windows, so the library is well- lit with natural lighting. Have solar panels. yes 18 Yes Brick Need to tie into high street better No to modern the brick is nice Needs to fit high street 19 Yes 20 Yes Bigger modern updates The one w bigger windows feels better the industrial one feels like a jail Yes Hurry up 21 Yes I like the nod to Moorpark’s farming past in the agrarian style choice. I don’t think the outside of either looks very welcoming. 22 Yes Agrarian style. It represents the beginnings of Moorpark, which to me, is important for others to know. No. Absolutely. Everyone can see the beginnings of Moorpark when on High Street. No. 23 Yes I like the lines on the agrarian design Sure 24 Yes Agrarian has a more cultural and warmer feel. Not a fan of the Industrial at all No 25 Yes The Agrarian style is warm, inviting, & looks like it would be a comfortable place for our community to engage & learn. I like the use of brick in the Industrial style & the nod to current architecture in the area. The Industrial style is a little cold & feels slightly out of place for our community. The Agrarian style is definitely fitting! With so much changing around us every day & becoming more & more modernized, I think the Agrarian style really captures a modern take on where our community came from, while still fitting in with the current architecture in the area. 26 Yes I like that the agrarian design incorporates Moorpark’s past but still looks modern. I don’t like the industrial design The agrarian one, Yes I don’t like the industrial design. I would like to see images of the planned interior 27 Yes I prefer the Agrarian design. It's more inviting and looks more like a building in a town rather than a big city. The industrial is clean but looks cold to me. No Not the industrial I think it would be a little sad to go with the cold industrial. A library should be a place that is inviting and kind. Moorpark Resident? What do you like about each design? Is there anything you would change about the designs? Do you think these designs are appropriate for High Street? Do you have any other comments about the styles to share with us? 28 Yes The agrarian design is welcoming. The industrial design honestly is too plain. There is nothing on the outside of the industrial design that says “people are welcome here.†On the industrial design i would avoid making it look like a big box. Consider having a wraparound terrace or wraparound shade so people can sit outside and enjoy the shade while reading and relaxing or using their laptops. The agrarian, yes. Industrial as currently design, no. Consider incorporating a small outdoor amphitheater into each design, so that there is a covered space for performances for 50-100 people. 29 Yes I like the agrarian option. It evokes a sense of place that is tied to Moorpark. I’m not a fan of the industrial option, it’s too generic I would have to see more visuals Yes I really prefer the agrarian option 30 No Light and open design. Perhaps, sky lights, as well yes Maybe a little lighter color on the exterior 31 Yes I like the Agrarian Architecture design. I love the high ceilings and I feel that it fits better in Moorpark. The industrial architecture design feels too much for the small town feel that Moorpark has. 32 Yes The Agrarian one looks much more inviting 33 Yes Windows They both look ugly and unappealing. Too modern, not classic. No. The barn style is prettier of the two but both look like ugly boxes. 34 Yes Agrarian design looks most appropriate for Moorpark’s image. Didn’t care for the industrial option. I like an industrial look but this design looked to commercial and dull. Lose the industrial design or make significant changes. Agrarian is. 35 Yes I love the Argraian design, it is more in keeping the the open country feel of Moorpark. BeauƟful! 36 Yes I like the agrarian design. Do not think the industrial design reflects Moorpark. Ni. Yes No Moorpark Resident? What do you like about each design? Is there anything you would change about the designs? Do you think these designs are appropriate for High Street? Do you have any other comments about the styles to share with us? 37 Yes The nod to Moorpark's past Yes I am glad the library is going to be bigger and will be able to hold more books and have dedicated areas. Our library holds a very special place in my heart. 38 Yes The Agrarian Architecture is more agreeable with me. Both are nice but the Industrial one is the one that looks repurposed. Like it was built for an industrial business, then became vacant, and later made into a library. Also too boxy. Knowing the location of the new facility and knowing the strong Santa Anna winds, I hope the outside porches face the best direction to reduce any potential wind issues. Yes both are appropriate but why not architecture that resembles the old high school's auditorium, on Casey Road? Not at this time. 39 Yes I like the clean look of the industrial style and imagine roof top social events would be awesome. The other design has great windows. Would love to see more color Both would work. I actually think the industrial is more fitting (to the likes of M on Highstreet) As I shared in the community meeting, would love to see solar panels, eco friendly features, native landscape, a place for outdoor events 40 Yes The Agrarian design would look better with our current architecture. It looks like it would let a lot of light in as well with the tall windows. I like the Industrial design, but I don't think it would feel as open and let enough light in. I think the Agrarian design is perfect. Yes, it would look beautiful on our lovely High Street. 41 Yes I like the agrarian design. It looks warm and welcoming. The industrial style looks cold and institutional and there is nothing special about it. The agrarian one is a good choice for High Street. 42 Yes I like the nod to farming and the large windows in that style. I also like the brick and exposed materials of the other design. I cringe when I hear the word modern used to describe anything high street. Yes, I think you could go even further with the ag/farm style. Maybe even the trees are “moorpark apricots†Look up the apricot lane farm building that never got built. I loved that style. 43 Yes Clean straight lines for both designs. Yes, both are appropriate. 44 Yes Outdoor areas lots of natural lighting Not a designer myself, but I do wish there were more options some thing in the middle of the two styles. Not sure; High Street has traditional architecture, so not sure if farm or industrial really fits the mold. I prefer the farm agrarian style, seems it would fit into High Street better. Moorpark Resident? What do you like about each design? Is there anything you would change about the designs? Do you think these designs are appropriate for High Street? Do you have any other comments about the styles to share with us? 45 Yes Like the agrarian one MUCH better. Not so boxy as industrial one. Like the large city seal on each. Name of the library is Moorpark City Library, ( not “public†) . While it a public library, we did not name it that. Please fix that. Yes, both would work, but agrarian one is much more beautiful. Landscaping should be all drought tolerant CA native plants. Not sure it is showing that, so far. 46 Yes I like the Agrarian Inspired Design 47 Yes Clean lines Yes I think it’s to modern for wheee it’s going I would rather keep to An old fashioned feeling like high street 48 Yes Agrarian has a warm and inviting feel to it but the industrial would compliment similar buildings on high st and other areas of moorpark I think the industrial design would fit better on high street 49 Yes I like the fact that both designs go with the aesthetic of High Atreet No Yes 50 Yes I like the barn design. I love the use of wooden beams and natural light. I like the shape of the outside. For the industrial design there is nothing I like. It is too boxy and uninviting. Industrial designs are cold and harsh. A library should be warm and inviting. It should feel cozy and draw people in. The agrarian style design does that. The industrial design is too boxy and the inside with open ceilings is a bad idea for a library where you want it to be quiet. I think noise control would be a problem. Yes Please do not choose the industrial style design. I think that would be a big mistake. 51 Yes Modern No Yes No 52 Yes The first is ok. The second is not attractive Add more character. Historic facade maybe.. Need to encompass more historical features. Na 53 Yes Agrarian - lots of windows and gabled roof; industrial is pretty but I prefer the Agrarian Both look good; I prefer more rustic Yes Vote for the agrarian style! Moorpark Resident? What do you like about each design? Is there anything you would change about the designs? Do you think these designs are appropriate for High Street? Do you have any other comments about the styles to share with us? 54 Yes I really like lots of windows, open feeling, and outdoor spaces of both. I prefer the look of the agrarian as I really like the high ceilings and open beams, lots of windows, and more natural look/feel. I think that more aligns with Moorpark and I think it looks more inviting. Whatever may be chosen, it needs to be inviting because a library is not used like a post office or DMV, it should be a place people/children can be comfortable while they read, research, etc. and the design should align with that. If there is intent to have things like story time reading to kids, or book club meetings, that require a gathering space, this should be included in the design - maybe ability/space to do an indoor and/or an outdoor one. 55 Yes Agrarian: local materials, homage to agricultural past, natural light Industrial: open spaces, wraparound porch Ag: which way does it face? Sun through windows could make it hard to air-condiƟon? Ind: design is closed-up, few windows, making it less appealing yes no 56 Yes Clean. Modern. Environmentally friendly. Perfect the 1st. Always adhere to your roots. Yes No 57 Yes Both styles allow for outdoor seating, which is a nice feature. I prefer the agricultural style building, with its peaked roof, and gray color. I like that the farm style hearkens back to Moorpark’s roots, yet has a modern look as well. I don’t have any changes to recommend. Both designs are appropriate, yet I think the industrial style is a bit plain. I’m delighted that the plans are coming along at last! It will be wonderful to have an up-to-date library! 58 Yes I like the Agrarian Inspired Design. It’s a more friendly and welcoming design. The Agrarian Inspired Design is, the other is cold. 59 Yes I really like the Agarian I feel it reflects the agricultural history of Moorpark. We also need to make sure it has classroom area for small Classes and also a snack bar with outdoor seating. We also need to make sure the children section shelves are reachable for children See above Yes Moorpark Resident? What do you like about each design? Is there anything you would change about the designs? Do you think these designs are appropriate for High Street? Do you have any other comments about the styles to share with us? 60 Yes I’m both, I like the wrap around patio. In the Agrarian Architecture: the floor to ceiling windows. Yes I prefer the Agrarian Architecture style. 61 Yes i like the openess of the windows and moderness of the agrarian but the rusty red/orange color of the industrial along with how it fits most librareys and the theme of highstreet well. I would make the agrarian more in theme with highstreet while maintaining its unqiue look. For industrial I would give it more character (so less boxy) and more modern to make it less boxy and more welcoming. Yes in my opionion i think both very beautiful and appropriate for high street. 62 Yes I like the Agrisn voice- has more character The Agrian fits into High Street 63 Yes The large size and the outdoor area. I would not do the industrial version. Too blocky without character and doesn’t go with High Street. Not the Industrial. I do like the Agrarian style with the large windows and open patio. More friendly and goes better with High Sreet. 64 Yes Prefer the agrarian inspired design because it's more similar to the anticipated environment Put a canopy over the porch area to encourage sitting. No one wants to sit in the direct sunlight The agrarian design is more fitting. The other is ok. No. 65 Yes I love the Agrarian style. It feels warm and inviting and love the outdoor seating. I think it goes better with the High St architecture. The Industrial design the brick is nice and it also has the outdoor seating area. No changes for the Agrarian design. The Industrial style reminds me of an old factory. I don’t like the square box shape. There is nothing that invites me in. The Agrarian one fits best One of my favorite libraries in the area is the Agoura library. 66 Yes Agrarian Architecture Is modern and welcoming. Instead of umbrellas, build a larger permanent shade structure in front. Yes the Agrarian style is. Industrial style is too cold and stern looking. Not appropriate for our small, family oriented city. 67 No I am a library user & like the open feel of the Agrarian one. The Industrial one looks boxy & confining. Yes Thank you for your efforts! 68 Yes Both include outdoor tables Yes 69 Yes Love the Agrarian! Moorpark Resident? What do you like about each design? Is there anything you would change about the designs? Do you think these designs are appropriate for High Street? Do you have any other comments about the styles to share with us? 70 No Prefer Agrarian Design. My traveling enables me to use a variety of local libraries for business work on my laptop. Libraries offering an environment of “rustic, organic, and comfortable†are typically more conducive to a pleasant working environment. Conversely, the Industrial “style is intended to be a nod towards the growth of Moorpark away from a farming community towards a modern industrial community with manufacturing and retail at its economic core†; that evokes a cold, meaningless and austere community and a “nod towards†today’s ‘it’s all about chasing the money’. Taking away the ‘country community’ atmosphere that is so attractive with your current facility. Focus on the restrooms and a dedicated clean-up custodian, a button to press to ensure toilets are flushed with signage, not overly modern water taps that take a long time to dispense water for hand washing and perhaps at least three sinks. Individual tables with computer outlets. CCTV cameras. At least four Handicap parking spaces. Diagonal parking. Water bottle friendly, the ones with sensors. Ensure Exits are in view of Reception to dissuade from articles taking “walkies†! This question appears to be a "one size fits all" generic. Apparently, the new library will be built on bucolic country land and not in the "High Street". Unless the City of Moorpark has plans to extend their "High Street"! Agrarian with a modern 'non-metalic' touch. Moorpark Resident? What do you like about each design? Is there anything you would change about the designs? Do you think these designs are appropriate for High Street? Do you have any other comments about the styles to share with us? 71 No Prefer Agrarian Design. My traveling enables me to use a variety of local libraries for business work on my laptop. Libraries offering an environment of “rustic, organic, and comfortable†are typically more conducive to a pleasant working environment. Conversely, the Industrial “style is intended to be a nod towards the growth of Moorpark away from a farming community towards a modern industrial community with manufacturing and retail at its economic core†; that evokes a cold, meaningless and austere community and a “nod towards†today’s ‘it’s all about chasing the money’. Taking away the ‘country community’ atmosphere that is so attractive with your current facility. Focus on the restrooms and a dedicated clean-up custodian, a button to press to ensure toilets are flushed with signage, not overly modern water taps that take a long time to dispense water for hand washing and perhaps at least three sinks. Individual tables with computer outlets. CCTV cameras. At least four Handicap parking spaces. Diagonal parking. Water bottle friendly, the ones with sensors. Ensure Exits are in view of Reception to dissuade from articles taking “walkies†! This question appears to be a "one size fits all" generic. Apparently, the new library will be built on bucolic country land and not in the "High Street". Unless the City of Moorpark has plans to extend their "High Street"! Agrarian with a modern 'non-metalic' touch. 72 Yes I like the openness and welcoming look of the Agrarian design. I like the frontage of the industrial design but feel so much brick presents a negative feeling toward the building. The industrial design reminds me of building that I worked in on the East Coast and couldn't wait to leave at 5pm. I would add warmth with a friendlier exterior - like flagstone rather than brick. I don't think the industrial design is appropriate - there are no factories or warehouses on High Street. Moorpark currently only has two features worth talking about - Moorpark College and the High Street Theater. The library could be a centerpiece of our town - a place to brag about. 73 Yes I like the natural light and rustic atmosphere of the agrarian design. n/a I think the agrarian design is appropriate for High Street. I think the agrarian design is more reflective of Moorpark. 74 Yes I like the style of the Agrarian design. It fits with the history of the community & is a beautiful structure. Yes Moorpark Resident? What do you like about each design? Is there anything you would change about the designs? Do you think these designs are appropriate for High Street? Do you have any other comments about the styles to share with us? 75 Yes The Agrarian one is friendly and approachable. It looks like a nice place to visit and spend Ɵme. I would throw away the Industrial one. Only the Agrarian one. I would love to sit on the patio and enjoy a good book. The Industrial one looks like yet another cookie cutter, tilt up, industrial building. It lacks character, doesn't really fit in with the feel of Moorpark or High Street. I like modern design but it just seems cheap and like something you could put up over a weekend. It is really ugly. 76 Yes I like the Agrarian style; it looks modern. no yes-either one. none. I'm excited to see the library grow! 77 Yes I like design one. It is more reflective of Moorpark and more unique than design two (the minimalist, industrial option). 78 Yes Agrarian - I like to windows and the use of outside light coming in. It looks inviting like a library should look. Industrial - looks institutional. I like NOTHING about this design. It is boxed and flat. It doesn't say "come in to read, gather, and learn." Did someone say GREAT prison design? They should have. What makes one design appropriate or not appropriate? That is a ridiculous question. High Street has a building that you closed down for no good reason and left a family without a business to run. Then there is a building that is unsafe for anyone to walk into. A closed thrift store that is a home for rats and spider. Let's see, we have a Veterinary practice, a couple of restraunts that continue to thrive, a fire station, a Metrolink parking lot, etc. I ask again, what makes a building appropriate for High Street. It isn't a brothel. It is a library for heaven's sake. No. Just build it and they will come. But it won't happen in my lifetime. 79 Yes They both use a lot of natural light and incorporate outdoor space, but the agrarian just looks nicer. Much nicer. I don’t like the boxy design of the industrial one. Sure. I think so. I don’t think it would look out of place. No. Moorpark Resident? What do you like about each design? Is there anything you would change about the designs? Do you think these designs are appropriate for High Street? Do you have any other comments about the styles to share with us? 80 Yes Each style looks well done, thought out and presumably will stand the test of time. I'm not a big fan of the metal Moorpark City Library sign on each design. It looks goofy and should instead be placed on the on wall instead of standing vertical. They seem to fit the area quite well. It would be interesting to know the building costs of each design as well as the environmental impact. The industrial brick design seems to be better suited for insulating the building compared the other design. 81 Yes Agrarian design is more attractive and welcoming in my mind. Industrial design looks too institutional. Not friendly Add some curves to the industrial design Yes No 82 Yes Not much. Too many windows, would cause too much glare inside. Industrial design looks more like a big box store, not inviting to patrons. I love the design/look of the Camarillo Library. It's a beautiful building outside. Inside is comfortable and welcoming. Let's do something like that. There's no "design" to High Street. Every building on the street is different. Doesn't matter if the library fits or not with what's present. The proposed High St. Depot has its own look, so nothing matches. Most people don't know about Moorpark history anyway. Need something that's pretty. These designs are too boxy and dull. Libraries shouldn't be dull. Needs artwork. 83 Yes I like how the Agrarian design feels welcoming and familiar. I like that the Industrial design feels modern and clean. No I think the Agrarian design fits better with the downtown atmosphere. 84 Yes I like the agrarian design. I like the the inviting outdoor areas especially with the agrarian design. Yes, especially the agrarian design. Even though Moorpark has a great deal industrial buildings, I feel remembering it’s agrarian beginning gives an calming atmosphere in this be very hectic often scary world. 85 Yes Open, large windows, use of outdoors I particularly like the more farm look to incorporate the vibe of Moorpark and the surrounding buildings on high street. I don’t think the more modern look would pull in the rest of the surrounding city scape and look of Moorpark and high street. 86 Yes Love the agricultural design as it seems to have more ligh and a cozier vibe. I don’t know about the interiors, but I’m hoping there will still be a children’s section and other genre areas along with comfortable chairs and tables Yes, either design would be appropriate for High Street I’m just hoping the final design with be people and family friendly along with adequate configurations for events. Moorpark Resident? What do you like about each design? Is there anything you would change about the designs? Do you think these designs are appropriate for High Street? Do you have any other comments about the styles to share with us? 87 Yes The amount of windows enabling natural daylight into the spaces is great! Looking great so far! Both are appropriate, but I prefer the Agrarian style. The Agrarian style seems classic, almost timeless, and more modern while the Industrial seems tied to a specific time period. 88 Yes I like the large windows on the front of the agrarian design. I like the agrarian design, but the stonework on the outside almost reminds me of designs seen in shopping centers from the 1970s. Neither style seems to match with what already exists on High Street, but both evoke a sense of historical reflection (as opposed to a completely modern looking building, which would be out of place). I am very excited that we are moving forwarded with a bigger and brighter library. :) 89 Yes There's no comparison! The agrarian design is warm and welcoming and I can imagine being inside with the light streaming in through the windows. Yes, the farm-like nature fits in with the old-timey feel of High Street. 90 Yes I only like the Agrarian Design Don't choose the industrial design only the Agrarian one is appropriate Please choose the Agrarian design 91 Yes I love the big windows and openness of them. I prefer the Agrarian design as it feels more comfortable and relaxing than the Industrial design. It also has a warmer feel. Yes, I think both are fine. Nope, just a preference for the Agrarian design. 92 Yes They are really pretty. Its beautiful just the way it is. Yes, they are good. I really liked the Agrarian design because it looked like a nice place to read in, and because it looked calming. I liked that in both of the designs they had an outside area. Moorpark Resident? What do you like about each design? Is there anything you would change about the designs? Do you think these designs are appropriate for High Street? Do you have any other comments about the styles to share with us? 93 Yes I like the front of the agrarian design better than the front of the industrial design. However, I do not like the backside of the agrarian design - it looks kind of disjointed. I do like the backside of the industrial design better, but it still reminds me of the look of an office building - cold & not user-friendly. The industrial design, overall, would fit better with the rest of High Street. My husband, who used to an architect (he's still licensed in the state of CA), commented that these designs are "uninspiring, 3rd-rated, vernacular - treating Moorpark like a backwards, unsophisticated city." My husband also said that there is no civic pride in these designs, as if we are only deserving of a barn house as a city library. He doesn't think the architecture firm that is hired understands what we, Moorparkians, want in a city library. He said the designs are not representative of our youths, who will be the main ones to enjoy the benefits of a new, modern, technology enhanced library. For reference, my husband worked on the San Francisco City Library as a design architect & construction manager. 94 Yes Both are very clean, modern, and sophisticated. I think the design incorporating our agricultural roots is just a little more fitting for Moorpark though. It’s rustic yet modern feel would fit naturally on high street, while allowing Moorpark’s many sunny days to flood the library with natural light. No, they’re both brilliantly and beautifully designed. The industrial design looks almost too much like a firehouse than a library, and isn’t as inviting if an exterior as the rustic agricultural design. Yes, but the rustic design is more so suited. No, like I’ve said before, both are brilliant and beautiful. 95 Yes High ceilings with glass windows and the arch of the roof. Display of a arm clock in the middle of the building. Along with utilizing solar panels. Yes Having glass that is tinted from outside but being able to see from inside to outside. Therefore, increasing energy efficiency. Also, art to be displayed such as title floor on the outside thats also wheelchair accessible. Moorpark Resident? What do you like about each design? Is there anything you would change about the designs? Do you think these designs are appropriate for High Street? Do you have any other comments about the styles to share with us? 96 Yes The industrial design is my preference but the agraan seems it would be more spacious Hopefully the interior will reflect the spacious look the agrarian design gives off. The library shouldn't so cramped as the current library is in some parts of the building but have room for activities the staff can set up. 159 Everett St 97 Yes The agrarian design feels warmer and more welcoming. I love the accordion door design included in both plans. nothing came to mind yes The large windows and wide-open facade of the agrarian concept feels more inviting. The industrial style didn't convey "come explore" to me. 98 Yes Outdoor space and natural light/windows for the inside No Yes, hopefully it will motivate other buildings to make improvements No 99 Yes I like the warthog of the Agrarian style over the coldness and factory- elements of the industrial style. No, but I do hope that there are separate computer areas for those who watch videos, movies and play games, and those who are doing research, seeking employment opportunities or locating news information. More or less. Perhaps a few posters outlining library rules and etiquette should be hung up. 100 Yes I prefer the agrarian design. The peaked roof lines are more interesting to my eye. yes 101 Yes The large windows yes I prefer the Agrarian design best. It has more style and is less severe-looking. I feel like I've seen the Industrial version for other libraries, and the Agrarian is more u;nique. 102 Yes Open airiness of both is nice. Outdoor area is great. I like the agrarian design best. Will there be solar panels? I like the Agrarian better. It would be nice to see some sketches of the inside as well. 103 Yes The windows and outdoor space No Yes No Moorpark Resident? What do you like about each design? Is there anything you would change about the designs? Do you think these designs are appropriate for High Street? Do you have any other comments about the styles to share with us? 104 Yes Regarding both designs (Agrarian Inspired and Industrial Inspired), I especially like the many large windows and other design elements that make the most of natural light; the use of accordion doors and windows that will allow programming to spill out into the porch areas is an interesting concept; I like the wraparound porch enclosed by the low wall on the south and east sides, which protects those seated there while allowing them to see beyond the wall. I like the wood and natural rock exterior shown on the Agrarian Inspired design and the wood beams that will be a design feature inside, as well as the outline or silhouette of the building. The brick materials used in the Industrial Inspired design (interior and exterior) are attractive. No, I would not change anything about the building designs. My only comments concern the areas outside the buildings, which I realize are shown only to give a sense of how the buildings could look in their setting but that may be different in reality. One suggestion I would make is to add bench seating on the west side of the building in the Agrarian Inspired design; this may not be feasible in the Industrial Inspired design, which has more full-length windows on the west side. Also concerning the landscaping that is shown: the water-wise garden on the south side is lovely; will the lawn area on the north side be sustainable with the coming water restrictions? Lawn areas invite people to congregate--I assume that a drought-tolerant turf would be used? Yes, I think both designs are appropriate for High Street (both designs blend in with buildings already there). I prefer the Agrarian Inspired design to the Industrial Inspired design for its warmer feel (in a previous survey community members said that what they liked about Moorpark was its warm, friendly atmosphere; I think the Agrarian Inspired design embodies this sentiment better). Also, while I love the exposed wood beams that will be a feature of the Agrarian Inspired interior, I've never been a fan of exposed duct work, which will be a feature of the Industrial Inspired design. The varied roof line of the Agrarian Inspired design is more interesting than the plain rectangular shape of the Industrial Inspired design. In short, I personally prefer warm/cozy to minimalist/utilitarian. 105 Yes Functional No open duct work...tends to date us. This is not a brewery. I guess I expected something more. Both designs were the same, interesting. No inside views..interesting. 106 Yes I prefer the Agrarian - like the windows and outdoor patio area. The design looks very inviƟng. The outdoor sitting area is very close to the parking lot/cars - it will distracting for patrons who are reading or conversing to have cars coming and going. Anyway to put the patio on the side away from the cars? Yes Can you make the entrance of the Agrarian a little more inviting? It's hard to tell exactly where the entrance is. 107 Yes I prefer the agrarian style.Yes Industrial is wrong for high street, 108 Yes I like the updated look They both could use changes. The barn one reminds me of a college cafeteria and the industrial one reminds of a classroom. No. I think it look like the M with big windows. Or if they are looking for a more brewery type vibe with wood and the high beams I think that new designs should be submitted 109 Yes All the windows No No No Moorpark Resident? What do you like about each design? Is there anything you would change about the designs? Do you think these designs are appropriate for High Street? Do you have any other comments about the styles to share with us? 110 Yes Nothing! These are both seriously ugly designs. What happed to the previous mission style library design? That was attractive. I vote Heck No on both designs. They are an embarrassment. start over no, and not for anywhere in Moorpark. What happened to the previous design????? 111 No I like how welcoming the Agrarian design looks, the tall-pointed windows seem like they'd give lots of light to the inside of the building and I like the stone as well. The Industrial design is nice, I like the brick but it does not stand out or look as welcoming as the Agrarian design. I like the Agrarian design and don't think any changes are needed. The Industrial design has metal beams holding up the awning around the front of the library and they look unwelcoming, like the awning is too heavy and could collapse. I think the Agrarian design is appropriate for High Street. The brick in the Industrial design matches high street but the metal awning does not. I think the Agrarian design matches the style of the whole city! The organic and farm elements tie in to what Moorpark is about. 112 Yes The massive windows! No The industrial more so than agrarian design for the current high street vibe. At the end of the day the building need to feel welcoming to every demographic especially the primary clientele. I hope the library has this advertised so current library patrons are ensured an opportunity to provide feedback. 113 Yes I really like the Agrarian Inspired design. The outside looks really nice. I like the big windows too! I don’t really like the outside facade of the other design. Yes. I’d love there to be a nice area for young children to go and play and also have a fun place to read. 114 Yes This is not what a 21st century library should look like. What you need is a scaled-down facility for holding small group meetings. And the rest of the library should be digital. That is all you need. No Moorpark Resident? What do you like about each design? Is there anything you would change about the designs? Do you think these designs are appropriate for High Street? Do you have any other comments about the styles to share with us? 115 Yes Neither is perfect. However, the "feel" of the "agrarian" is somewhat more welcoming and warm. I do not like the squat appearance of the urban style. Many openings to the area surrounding either building is good for enjoymnet of patrons. Perhaps if the urban design had a more elevated section for its entrance, and the brick is unacceptable. I would have less glass in the agrarian style. I would immediately include solar panels in the design for either one. I would not have exposed pipes etc. for the urban style. I think that is now passe (not exactly a bold new concept). It's a little hard to determine what exactly defines High Street since there are so many different examples of architecture. The brick and square design of the urban style in its current form would be at home in Baltimore, not Southern California. The amount of glass in the agrarian style may be inappropriate for earthquake country. Perhaps some combination of solid panels and glass? 116 Yes Although it doesn't "wow" me, I prefer the Agrarian design. The Industrial option doesn't feel like it's welcoming me in to explore. I love the high ceilings and large expanses of glass of the Agrarian option. I would ask that great effort be made to obtain the highest possible LEED certification. Where is solar roof? Or solar covered/shaded parking? High Street is such a hodgepodge of styles and eras already and lacks a public rallying around any particular future image/function. I'd rather see an awesome library - whatever that is - inspire the future of High Street and not worry about "fitting in" with the existing mess. 117 Yes Both designs seem to offer lots of natural light and openness throughout due to the large amount of space devoted to windows. In the Industrial design, the harsh corners created by a flat roof and the brick exterior seem cold and unwelcoming. No changes at this time for the Agrarian design. Agrarian, yes; Industrial, no. Nothing further...yet. 118 Yes They look interesting The industrial design is better for downtown Moorpark. 119 Yes Big windows for a lot of natural light! I think giving more natural light on the Agrarian style would be best. I love the big windows in the back of the Industrial style, but the front of the building looks uninviting and has no character. I only thing the Agrarian design ins appropriate for High Street. I just wish it utilized a lot more of the windows in the back and the natural light. We are at the library multiple time a week, and if your going to spend so much money on a new facility, utilize the light and some style that has character. The Industrial style has not character and looks like it would be done to cut cost. I'm all about having a simple outside, if that means spending more money on the interior. It just looks cheap and uninviting, especially for the kids that will have story time and activities there. Moorpark Resident? What do you like about each design? Is there anything you would change about the designs? Do you think these designs are appropriate for High Street? Do you have any other comments about the styles to share with us? 120 Yes Agrarian Inspired Design Is the one I only care for. Would not change anything. Perfect for High street. Reflects the mood and style of Moorpark very well. 121 No I like the openness and natural light of the Agrarian Inspired Design. I think if it is done well, it can make the library very inviting, warm, comfortable, and modern. It does seem like it may get hot in the summer months with all the windows though. The industrial design has a nice patio area, but it looks a lot less modern and not as welcoming in my opinion. For the Agrarian Inspired Design, I would suggest making it so that the windows aren’t facing the hot sun. I don’t much care for the Industrial design though. Yes, the Agrarian Inspired Design looks beautiful and I think it would fit in very well with the look of the surrounding community. I hope that whichever design is chosen, there is a nice patio area to read or have programs on. I would also like to see a more fun and enclosed children’s area inside the library so that they feel safe and able to enjoy the programs without worrying about other patrons. Several meeting or conference rooms would be great as well.