Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutAGENDA REPORT 2012 0718 CC REG ITEM 09E ITEM 9.E. City Council Fleeting MOORPARK CITY COUNCIL AGENDA REPORT TO: Honorable City Council FROM: David A. Bobardt, Community Development Director Prepared by: Joseph R. Vacca, Principal Planner DATE: July 5, 2012 (CC Meeting of 7/1812012) SUBJECT: Consider Lighting Consultant Comments on Updated Lighting Plan Related to Ventura County Planning Commission Approval of Minor Modification No. 3 to Conditional Use Permit No. 4915 for the Tom Barber Golf Center (LU10-0087) BACKGROUND/DISCUSSION On September 1, 2011, the Ventura County Planning Commission approved, by a 3-1 vote, Minor Modification No. 3 to Conditional Use Permit No. 4915, which, among other things, extended the permit for the Tom Barber Golf Center from 2017 to 2037. Lighting from the Tom Barber Golf Center has been an ongoing concern of the City. The permit extension hearing offered an opportunity for the County Planning Commission to make changes to the lighting conditions, if the Commission found the lighting to be a public nuisance; however, the Commission did not make that finding and did not call for any changes to the lighting. On September 9, 2011, following the direction from City Council at their September 7, 2011 meeting, staff filed an appeal of the decision of the County Planning Commission. The public hearing on the appeal was scheduled and noticed to be heard by the Board of Supervisors on February 28, 2012. However, the applicant requested a continuance to allow more time to address outstanding lighting concerns, and the item was continued to be renoticed at a future Board meeting. The applicant hired Musco Lighting to develop a redesign of the lighting on the Tom Barber Driving Range in response to comments from the City's lighting consultant. The proposed lighting would eliminate all ground-mounted lighting, replacing it with nine (9) seventy (70) foot high poles with two lights on each pole aimed downward instead of at a 90 degree angle to the ground. The existing pole mounted lights behind the tees would be aimed downward at a 30 degree angle, instead of being aimed horizontally straight out. The new proposed poles would be a similar height to the sports lights used in Arroyo Vista Park as well as the high voltage power lines on Tierra Rejada Road adjacent to the driving range. Staff met with County planning staff and the applicant on 22 Honorable City Council July 18, 2012 Page 2 site on May 23, 2012, to review the updated lighting plan; and also forwarded the new plan to Teri Jackson, Moorpark's Lighting Consultant of Seaport Lighting Inc. Ms. Jackson has indicated, (letter attached) that upon review of all supporting documents provided concerning the newly proposed Musco lighting system for the Golf Center, the proposed lighting strategy would achieve the goals of reducing off-site glare from the driving range. Staff believes that it is appropriate to submit to the County a letter of support for this revised design, provided that the existing application is withdrawn and a new application is submitted with the lighting revised as proposed in the new lighting plan. In addition to providing comments on the lighting, staff would also comment on the perimeter landscaping to make sure it is brought into compliance with approved landscaping plans and that additional trees are added to screen the new light poles. STAFF RECOMMENDATION Authorize staff to submit a letter of support for a new application for an extension of the Conditional Use Permit with the lighting revised as proposed in the new lighting plan, upon the applicant's withdrawal of the current application. Attachments: 1. Musco Lighting Letter Dated June 8, 2012 Proposed Revisions i. New Proposed Lighting Design — Using 9 70' Poles ii. 3 Local Driving Range Layouts Musco Lighting has Completed and Installed iii. 2 Fixture Pole Drawing iv. Picture of the Proposed Fixture to be Used v. Pole Height Chart Comparing a Shorter 40' Pole to a 70' Pole vi. Pole Height Chart with Different Pole Heights vii. Evolution of Light viii.Project References 2. June 26, 2012 Letter from Teri Jackson, LC, MIES, Lighting Consultant with Seaport Lighting, Inc. SACommunity Development\OTHER AGENCIES\Ventura County\Tom Barber Golf_CUP\20120718 CC Agenda Report Updated Lighting.doc 23 Corporate: 100 1st Ave West PO Box 808 Oskaloosa, IA 52577 641/673-0411 800/825-6020 Fax:641/673-4852 Manufacturing: 2107 Stewart Road PO Box 260 Muscatine: IA 52761 • 563/263-2281 8001756-1205 Fax: 800/374-6402 CCX:0 Web:wtvt^r.musco.com Email: lighting@musco.com Mus June 8, 2012 City of Moorpark Mr. David Bobardt—Community Development 799 Moorpark Ave Moorpark, CA 93021 RE: Tom Barber Golf Center Dear Mr. Bobardt am writing this letter in conjunction with the meeting held at the Tom Barber Driving Range on May 23, 2012. Reason being - new proposed lighting at the driving range. After many meetings with Mr. Barber, about light tress pass on the surrounding areas, Musco Lighting has came up with a new design utilizing pole mounted fixtures down each side of the driving range in lieu of existing berm fixtures. The new proposed lighting system utilizes 9—70' poles with 2 Musco Light Structure Green fixtures on each pole, the fixtures will be aimed to a 30 degree angle to help mitigate the offsite spill and glare. The poles will be located down each side of range with 5 poles on the east side and 4 poles on the west side. The fixture total for the new proposed lighting system will be 18 fixtures compared to the 34 fixtures they currently use. The visor will be our 14" inch spill and glare control providing 50% better light control over the fixtures currently in use. Musco has helped design and install many sports lighting venues in the surrounding areas including but not limited to CLU football, 5 Conejo parks and rec fields, Ventura County Softball park, Oxnard sports park, College park Oxnard, Moorpark High school, Oaks Christian High School and Middle School, 3 parks for Pleasant Valley parks and rec. I have also attached a reference list for you to review. Along with this letter I have attached sever pieces of info for you: 1 —New proposed lighting design— using 9 70' poles. 2—3 local driving range layouts we have completed and installed. 3—2 fixture pole drawing 4— Picture of the proposed fixture to be used 5—Pole height chart comparing a shorter 40' pole to a 70' pole 6—Pole Height chart with different pole heights 7—Evolution of light—compares the new technology to the existing 8—Project references. Lighting . . . We Make It Happen. CC ATTACHMENT 1 24 You will see Musco has made great advances in the Sports Lighting industry, with over 30 year of developing new products and designs, if you have any question or concerns please do not hesitate to call me and I will glad to answer any question or provide you with any additional information you may need. Sincerely, Michael Winfrey Musco Sports Lighting 949-754-0503 ext 6116 mike.winfrey @musco.com Enclosure 25 0000 musco. GREEN GEiIERATiON LIGHTING'" GUARANTEED PERFORMANCE *1111:2 Ji 14 61 111 A • P6 Tom Barber Golf Driving Range Moorpark,CA INCLUDES: Driving Range P7 Electrical System Requirements: Refer to Amperage O Draw Chart and/or the"Musco Control System Summary" for electrical sizing. P8 Installation Requirements:Results assume+/-3% nominal voltage at line side of the ballast and structures O O located within 3 feet(1m)of design locations. P1 EQUIPMENT LIST FOR AREAS SHOWN \ P9 Pole LuminaPE CITY LOCATION SIZE ELEVATION HEIGHT TYPE ' POLE 9 I P1,P10 70' 70' 150OW MZ 2 P2 P2-P4 P6-P9 i 9 -TOT) 18 �D iving Range SINGLE LUMINAIRE AMPERAGE DRAW CHART G.2 Ballast Specifications Line Amperage Per Luminaire (.90 min power factor) (max draw) P3 Single Phase Voltage 208 220 1 240 277 347 380 480 P10 (60) (60) (60) (60) (60) (60) (60) 1500 watt MZ 8.6 1 7.7 7.5 6.51 5.1 1 - 1 3.7 P4 By:Alex Nielsen SCALE IN FEET 1 :200 File#:157590r3 Date:19-Apr-12 Pole location(s)+dimensions are relative Not to be reproduced in whole or part without the written 0119 to 0,0 reference point(s) consent of Musco Lighting.©1981,2012 Musco Lighting 0' 200' 400' 0) Print Date(19/Apr/2012)8 Time(13:30) EQUIPMENT IST FOR AREAS SHOWN Pole Luminaires C000 OTY LOCATION 512E GRADE MOUNTING LAMP OTYI OTHER _ _.. _ _ _ _ T.I.I GRIDS_ 9 P1 P10 70 70 1500W MZ 2- 2 0 �� OA P,2-P4 L P,6-P9 s 4 — TOTALS 1 s —is o— GREEN GENERATION LIGHTING' GUARANTEED PERFORMANCE Driving Range 69, Tom Barber Golf Driving Range —�{ P6 Moorpark,CA Range Size:2'x 2' .,° qp sQ "� Grid Spacing=30.0'x 30.0' ,09 q, Values given at 3.0'above grade 4 oB „2p sS J2 9 Luminaire Type: Green Generation °s s$e, •?, Rated Lamp Life: 5,000 hours P7 Avg Lumens/Lamp: 134,000 sop CONSTANT ILLUMINATION o� °a-0 -0s o s•,�' s,�s HORIZONTAL FOOTCANDLES J7 so �s Entire Grid O� op oy •?° s a a �? �s es <16Z P8 No.of Target Points: 415 •1? J •7S, .73, •,) t?,l- .B , S Jo 9 s R 3 Average: 4.5 1� .�S i 'o, o s ys os a Maximum: 12 ° Minimum: 0 Avg/Min: 24.42 413' 3�3p ?�9 ° 9�S �o,,;• a ��ash, ,moo`SV 2'qs s�� �o J d3 •?9.° Max/Min: 67.76 �S 4 z UG(Adjacent Pts): 5.13 s, 'J° sv s° 3 a3 R 9 3s�, oy 60 -0 CV: 0.55 a�s Ws s° s� a�s Rs '� .s�3 �� Rs ss •'p so 2n' P9 Average Lamp Tilt Factor: 1.000 -6' 2 sv s 4o s ss R6, �?2 °so 9 s� Avg KW over 5,000:Luminaires: 28.15 p344' a� •P •ss -rs ,;'z '?' ',.,, 2,,;• •q� 'ss ''� "r' N Max KW: 30.6 7 '�S �S '92 JOQ J9 $ ,, cQ •£2 'o s ,� J �� �2 g Guaranteed Performance:The CONSTANT f?2 s2 .s ds ss A� s J� •� `�, ILLUMINATION described above is guaranteed for the rated J ° °AS .s,60 ,e" ,ro life of the lamp. 9 p J .mss •?� "To �, ,� Field Measurements:Averages shall be+/-10%in P3 �`–��–° '� '' .6'2 RS .0 8 o^?o �s "s4 accordance with IESNA RP-6-01 and CIBSE LG4. Individual d�,0 s�?p ° �p.S "Sp �? 2 5"� P10 measurements may vary from computer predictions. ?s e s 2 s ?, , Electrical System Requirements: Refer to Amperage CA S•o? �a, •es s2 A9� ��� 6'qo 'ss &Q y '?o J '° Draw Chart and/or the"Musco Control System Summary" ,y „9p Jp '9v .9 ''� A ,S �3 '�O, •9 for electrical sizing. P4 394, �JQ�o dAJ°s2�2�?p��'?S�2 ���5�B R, �' s�9 s��s a'8J, nominal voltage ge at line side of Results he(ballast and structures s �� located within 3 feet(1 m)of design locations. 9 By:Alex Nielsen SCALE IN FEET 1 :150 File#:157590r3 Date: 19-Apr-12 Pole location(s)+dimensions are relative Not to be reproduced in whole or part without the written to 0,0 reference point(s) 53 consent of Musco Lighting.©1981,2012 Musco Lighting 0' 150' 300' Print Date(19/Apr/2012)&Time(13:30) EQUIPMENT LIST R AREAS SHOWN Pole Luminaires �� 9 P1 P10 SIZE GRADE MOUNTING LAMP 1OLF TNIS OTHER _ _ELP.VATION.__ HEIGHT_-_ TYPE _ 3QL€ _GRID_ GRIDS CITY P2-P4 70' 70' 1500W MZ 2 2 0 MU 01a P6-P9 - - s - TOTA�s- _ - -- -18 _ee GREEN GENERATION LIGHTING'" GUARANTEED PERFORMANCE O.o 0.o 00 0.0 p.0 p0 p.0 p.0 PO p.0 00 p.0 PO p.0 p.0 PO 0.0 0.0 0.o 00 00 p.0 p.0 po p.0 p.0 p.0 P 0.o.00 0.o p.0 00 p.0 Driving Range p.0 0.0 0.0 P.O 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0.00 p.0 0.0 0.0 p.0 0.0 PO 0.0 0.0 0.0 p.0 0.0 p.0 0.0 0.0 00 0.0 p.0 0.0.00 0.0 O.o 00 0.0 0.0 0.0 Tom Barber Golf Driving Range 0.0 0.0 0.0 p.o 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 p.0 p.0 0.o 0.0 P.O 0.0 0,0 0.0 PO.00 P.O p.0 p.o p.0.00 0.0 p.0 p.0 PO 0.0 P.0 P.o 0.0 p.0 0.0 Moorpark,CA 0.0 0.0 p.0 p.0 0.0 P 0.0 00 0.0 0.0 p.0 p.0 0.0 0 p.0 p.0 p.0 p.1 p.1 r69•p.o. .0 0.0 p.0 p.0 p.o 0.0 0.0 p.0 00 0.0 0.0 p.0 Grid p.0 p.0 p.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 p.0 D0 p.0 4).0 p 0 p.0 0.0 00 p.0 p.1 p.2 03 05-ps-'r.A�}.4 q o 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 p.0 00 p.o 0.0 p.0 p.0 •Size:2'x 2' 0.0 0.0 O.o 0.0 p.0 P p.0 0.0.0 .0 0.0 00 0.0 P.O po P 1 0.2 04 0.8 J.7 3.8.4 81".2 p.6 p.1 p., 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 O.o 0.0 0.0 Grid Spacing=30.0'x 30.0' 0.0 0.0 p.0 10.0 0.0 0.o 0.0 00 0.0 0.0 00 0.0 0.0 01 0.1 0.3 0s 4.2 2.7 54 6.6 .4. N5 p.3 0.1 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 00 p.0 0.0 p.0 Values given at 3.0'above grade p.o p.0 P.O 0.0 p.0 P P 00 0.0 0.0 P 0.0 P p., p.2 P J.0 2.1 .4.o.7.0 6.9 3. J.6 P p.1 0.1 0.0 PO 0.0 PO p.0 PO p.0 0.0 0.0 p.0 0.0 p.0 . 0.0.0.0 p.0 0.0 0.0 00 0.1 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.7 36 3.1 6.4 6.5 5.6 2.7 ,.2 0.5 p.2 0.1 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 p.o 0.0 •Luminaire Type: Green Generation Rated Lamp Life: 5,000 hours p.o 0.o go 0.o 0.0 0,0 O.o p.o P p., p., p., p.2 pa ps J.o 2.0 3.6 32 5.988.3.2�3 P7o.a J0.2 o., o., P.O P.O P 0.0 00 P •Avg Lumens/Lamp: 134,000 .90 0.0 0.0.0 I)L 0.0 0.0 p.0 p., 01 p.1 p.1 p.2.03 0 a p.e,.3 6.8 5.2--1 p.5 0.2 0., p.1 00 P 0 p o 00 P 0 p o CONSTANT ILLUMINATION p.o O.o O.o 0 0.0 0.0 0, p., p.2 p.z p,z ps D.4 p.4 p.6 0.9 J.7 6 3.3 a 5.2 7.6 7.5 I p.9 p.3 p., p., o., P o.o o.o p.o 00 HORIZONTAL FOOTCANDLES 0.0 pa 0 0.0 p.0 p.0 01 p.3 p.3 pA 0.5 P6 0.7 0.8 J.0 J.4 3.9 2 s.7.5 6.8.79.,52J P8.2 p.1 0.1 0.0 p.0 0.0 O.o PC 0 .0 0 0 0 1 3 7 8 0.1.3 J.5 3.5 J.5 7 J.9 2.1 2.5 3.9 1 3 3 3 2 7�1. 4 1 1 31 0.0 0.0 30 0o Entire Grid 0, 0 . 0. 0. 0 D 0. 0 J J. 5 5 5 5 2. _ p o No.of Target Points: 1292 0.00.0 .0 p.0 p.0..20.7.7.6.1.92.53.02.9.2.9 .62.32.12.12.e30. .1 .7.7.7.7 1.3 7,1 3. J. .30.1 p.1 p.7 0.0 P.O p.0 Average: 1.5 p.o 00 p.o .o D.o OA J4,3'o.4 A 6.z 6.3.4.6 s 3.o a 2.1 2.z 3. z J,6 3.z 3.7 7.4 5. �I o o., p., p., p.o p.o p.a Maximum: 12 0.0 00 0.0 p.0 019.�3Ts-J.3 7.2 6.3.5.3 5 3.6 0 2.6 2.8 3. .5 73 6.7.7.5.7.3.4, J.6 p8 0.3 p.1 p.1 p.0 p.0 p.0 Minimum: 0 Avg/Min: 5969.64 0.0 00 00 p.0 p.0 2.4 6.0 6.0 6.2 67 52 6., .4.5.19 3.6 3.5 3.6 3.6 33 51 .7.1 70 6.7 5.3 217'.1.5 P.-.3 p., p1 0.1 p.0 0.o Max/Min: 49144.99 0.0 p.0 p.0 0.0 el p.2 0 2.8 3.3.4.2.4.9 5.6 6.6 6.3.4.8.4.1 3.5.3,1 2.9 3.5 4;8 57 6.9 57 6.7 6.0 ✓ p.3 0.1 P 1 0.1 P.O p.0 UG(Adjacent Pts): 152.23 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 p., D33 .1.0 2.5344. 6.4.7.6.7.4 6.2.4.9 3.7 3.0 2.7 2.8 34.4.0.4.1 .4.6 6.8 6.5.7.4 6. O.a 0.2 0.1 0., 0.0 0.o CV: 1.63 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.1 3.7.3-6.6 6.7 6.2 J., 6.8 a.5 3,7 3.2 3.1 2.2 32 3.6 as 6.6 13.6,0.403 �.o 0.2 P 10.1 0.0 0.0 Average Lamp Tilt Factor: 1.000 p.0 p.0 p.0 p.0 p.0 p.o 01 1 .1.6 6.0.7.1 J_3 J.4.7.3 6<54.4.5 3. 3.1 2.8 9 3.7 5.z.7.5 6.8 0.4 5A J., 0.3 0.1 p.1 p.0 Ao Number of Luminaires: 18 po po 0.0 0o p.0 0.0 0u, , 8 34 .5 62.7., 6.6 6.1 6.2*41 , .2, 2 .4.1 6.5 6.7.7.8 .7.2 6.1 p.8 pA p.1 01 p.0 0.0 Avg KW over 5,000: 28.15 Max KW: 30.6 .0.00.0 0.0.0.00.0 p.0 P.O�� .53.0.7.06.0.7.9 5 .5.7.4.33.22. 3.32.5 .1 .4.0.4.56.76.7 6.0.4.2 _^.5 03 0.1 p.i 0.00.0 O.0 p.0 P.0 P.0.0.00,00.0p, .6.7.46.0.7.6 706.1 .4.83.83.22.92.93.13.33.7.4.901 6.63..6} P40.2 P10., 00 p.0 0.0 0.0 p.0 p.0 00 D0 0.0 PR .320,9 .1 J.0 JA J.0 6.4 6.4.4.3 3.5 3.D.2.8 3.2 a.7 7.1 66 p3 J.3' .9 0.4 0.2 P1 p,0 P.0 PO Guaranteed Performance:The CONSTANT p.0 0.o p.0 p.D P.O p.0 p.0 P.CM3. .1,1 .4 1 57 2,1 02 Ja 52 5�0 3.8 30 .26 28 .4,2 6.7 91 Jz32- 15'12 P100,2 0.' PO 00 00 ILLUMINATION described above is guaranteed for the rated 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 p.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0 .1gy0 6.6 64 J0.3S.1 .7.2 5.3 J.7 2.7 2.3 2A 34 6.3.7.0 6.4.10.209 87 .2 0.8 01 0.1 0.0 0.0 ps life of the lamp. 0.0 p.0 0.0 0.o po 0.0 0.0 0.0 D.1 7T8 50 02 6.8 J.2 6.1 .4.8 3.5 2.6 2,1 2�3 z9 35 3.9 6.8 7.9.7.6 5.5 J.3 0.6 P P 0.0 p.0 P.O Field Measurements:Averages shall be+/-10%in 0.o ,o 0.o 0.o 0.o p.o 0.o o.oP3 A.304'a5 6.4 5,2.4 6 3.9 30.2 J.9 J�7.17 J�7 2.3 .4.3 6.7.4.6 p.7 P4 01 P 1 0.o p.0 00 accordance with IESNA RP-6-01 and CIBSE LG4. Individual 0.0 0.0 O.o p.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 p.0 0.1 0. .0 9 1.1 .7 7 . JA P4 0-2 PA 00.0.0 0.0 0.0 measurements may vary from computer predictions. 0.0 p.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 p.0 0.0 p.1 p., p.2 0.6 0.6 0.8 J.1 J.0 p.9 p.7 p.6 0.6 p.6 p.7 J.1 .1A.1., 0,8 P.5 02 01 01 0.0 0.0 p.D P.O Electrical System Requirements: Refer to Amperage p.0 p.0 p.0 0.0 p.0 p.0 00 0.0 0.1 P1 0.1 02 0�3 03 04 04 p.4 p.4 0.a p.3 0.a 0.5 0s 06 0.4 p.4 0.3 p.1 P1 00 0.0 0.0 0.0 4P.0 Draw Chart and/or the"Musco Control System Summary" 0.00.00.00.00.00.00.00.00 o.0.10.1 01 p.2 p.202 p.20.2020.20,20.20.30.3 p.20.z p.2 p.10.10.0 p.0 p.0 p.00.o p.0 for electrical sizing. p.0 p.0 0.0 0.0 p.0 p.0 0.0 0.0 P p.0 0.1 0.1 p.1 P.1 P1 P I a, 0.1 0.1 01 0,2 0.2 0.1 0, 0.1 01 0.1 0.0 p.0 0.0 0.0 O.o 00 0.0 Installation Requirements:Results assume+/-3% 0.0 00 0.0 p.0 0.0 00 0.0 0.0 00 0.o 0.0 0.0 0.o P 1 0, 01 a1 P,1 01 01 p, P.1 01 01 01 .0.1 0.0 0.0 P.O D0 p0 p0 0.0 oa nominal voltage at line side of the ballast and structures 0.o p.0 0.0 0.0 p.0 PO p.0 0.0 PO p.0 p.0 0.0 0.0 p.0 p.0 Do p.0 0.1 01 01 P 1 Al 0.1 0.0 p.0 p.0 p.0 p.o 00 p.0 p.0 p.0 00 0.0 located within 3 feet(1 m)of design locations. p.o p.0 0.0 p.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.o 0.0 P 0 0.0 P.O p.0 0.0 0.0 00 p.0 0.0 00 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 p.0 go 0.0 p.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 By:Alex Nielsen File#:157590r3 Date: 19-Apr-12 SCALE IN FEET 1 :200 Pole location(s)$dimensions are relative Not to be reproduced in whole or part without the written to 0,0 reference point(s) (�o consent of Musco Lighting.©1981,2012 Musco Lighting Pk o' 200' 400' Print Date(19/Apr/2012)&Time(13:30) 00 N I _ I� m Vol Polo L � uminaires a~ �ma .� c � t pt 80• b' 74' 1500W Mz a e 0 I P2 DO' -9' 7' 1500w MZ B 8 0 musco 80 1800W MZ 6 8 0 3Y F ■■ ■ e 1 Ps eo• .te 64' a o �Y a��s GREEN GENERATION LIGHTING" 1 P6 80- -22' 68' WIZ M2 6 8 0 1 TI l8i 80' 1500w ML 8 6 D GUARANTEES PERFORMANCE 6 T TALE 38 38 0 q P2 —"�P3 RectanglieFleld9 � Carl60ed Golf Driving Range ® Carlsbad,CA R Tes Box Size:T z 2' Grid Spacing•10.0'x 10.0' Values given at 3.0'above grade 11 P1 Luminaire Type: Green Genergtlon n » » » r n a -Rated Lamp LI(e 5000lf- » » » » » » » » Avg LumenelLamp: 13q 000 COST NORNZONTAL P OTCANDLES Starlsllcal a » J+ Jr » » n Area y r JJ J n » n No.of Target Points: 136 Maxime u m 43 Minlmur, 13 T1 Ag7Mrm 2.37 e ) 334 UG(Adlawnt nt pas) 1 0 CV. 0 Average Lamp Till Fee, I o3o a r » +> » » » Number of Luminaires: 33 Avg KW over 5000 hours: 59.43 Max KW for Sizing Transformer. 64.0 r Guar-teed Performance:The CONSTANT ILLUMINATION described above is guaranteed for the rated J J » JJ life of Ue lamp. Measurements:Averages shad be+0.10%in wrdance vAth IESNA RP-6.01 and CIBSE 1-04.Individual J� measuramemm may vary from camputer predkti0ns. Eleettleal System Requirements;Refer to Amperage Draw C Nan and/or Ina"Muaco Control System Summary" for electrical skring. Inabllation Requirements:Results assume-1.3% nominal voltage At line side of the ballast and structures P5 located within 3 feet(iml of desigh loeatlons, 6—w PB By:Man Smith Date'.17-Aug-06 SCALE IN FEET 1 60 Polo 16G File :110092x6 tgn(e) kimenaiani® ors MlatiW k a 67 12c' la 0.0 of na points)® Not to be reprodueed to whole or pan without the written Consent of Muaco Lighting.01981,2006 MOSCO Lighting Print Dab It 7.uW2W6)L Tlma(09:32) W Fixture Type: LV-8 MZ EQUIPMENT LISTING ANAHEIM, CA TIGER WOODS FOUNDATION Lamp Type: 1500W MZ Pole Pole Mounting Pao Flzt. Kilow DRIVING RANGE Lumens: 155000 count locaton height Nae Elev. /uNt JunA File#/Date: 104103dm3/17-Nov-2004 6 P1-P6 7a 70' o' 3 4.e Prepared By: MARK BELLOMA 2 Tl-T3 70' 70' 1 01 1 5 1 8 7d Apo�tS C= musco® GUARANTEED PERFORMANCE _ INITIAL ILLUMINATION RECTANGLE P6 I 121.0' 10 0 I P5 HORIZONTAL FOOTCANDLES �I ON PLANE AT Z= 3 ° Target Points: 50 Average: 27.68 Maximum: 36.24 Minimum: 18.86 Avg/Min: 1.467 Max/Min: 1.921 UG(Adj pts) 1.537 _ CV: 0.183 P4 I 118.0' 112.0' I P3 Number of Luminaires: 28 *KW Consumption: 44.80 w w Q o} "Average Tilt Fa 0.932 "`Recoverable Light ht Loss Factors:x 1.000 Total Light Loss Factor(LLF) 0.932 *Refer to amperage draw for electrical sizing. **Additional non-recoverable Light Loss Factors are design constants equal to 1.0 at maintained illumination levels. P1 118.0' 11 0 I P2 —Includes Luminaire Dirt Depreciation and Lamp Lumen Depreciation-per IESNA o o} Lighting Handbook 9th Edition,page 9-17. NOTE:Light level averages and uniformities are guaranteed by MUSCO. However, Individual location measurements may vary from computer predictions. INSTALLATION REQUIREMENTS: Results assume+-3%nominal voltage at load side of ballast box and poles located within Ti I 60.0' 60.0' I T3 3 feet of design locations. COPYRIGHT(C)1981,2004 MUSCO SPORTS LIGHTING-Not to be reproduced in whole or part without the writ- ten consent of Musco Sports Lighting. =Pole Location SCALE IN FEET Pole location dimensions are relative to.0,0 reference point (9. 0 120 240 Lk) i j§tn °YS Px Poletop luminaire assembly 1 1 -Galvanized steel pole - -Electrical components- enclosure 0 10ft (3000 mm) I L LAF Groundlevel ------ ____ ___ Precast concrete base PRELIMINARY $c°„ 0 Musco Light-Structure System T pole 0000 CORPORATE OEXE: (2)metal halide Green Generation T"'luminaires P.O.a..e0e ' j 100 10 Aw WM ■ AA rn Z Oakalooaa,lore 52577 c ro N Typical configuration .1 ,:800♦,-611-673-0111 32 g T ai �kr.2"aP *aw�w r \. 4 r Vie^ 1/ ©2005,2006 Musco Lighting•Patents issued and pending BP-5-1 r Light-Structure 1, . A OEM WE w ar zf ^:..T w. } t - '7r•y'4.,,, � '^hi "i=�s ,t rs.. iy' `i`� C .£� :;.+, 41 ^�,`d.,- '2rM ,y,. 1;'x: 'mot n�� .., �:,.: v •,"�� •,..:.-: '�- � � � � � -��:.'- Jk l�7 "d§ 1 Y,., E`?�AM !":�.�°f� .!N ,41' :X tF �_.-T. +u�y, �v� E ,;, 'h..V � ��'Y i5''� p��:'� �.Ilwk�� W rF,��f��^ '.l� � f �.+ �I lf.�'. a�_ Pr`^�,•,�l V S -,-,� '.,e,.-r Y' ':t _ +a z, Jar��� ?� �' t: «s- wt .`n' � ,d� c`�.t.••S r .� ...t r+�f�. ;4 � .a.•�'as,m.u9}k• ,:�'} .x:ra j ,:: ., ., -.— .• i...� :, rc�tli� � ,� Yf��`ty �„.a '.o- 4sr�13��°'� ax-,.�;! kytY.�l''<F w �s �,.. Iii. `.:A�:, �"Ja wa �� ... Fi - ,�:: ,;:'....: �. .' _-__- - .�: ,.. ;.: � ,'�� '�;:.w is },y,D.wa+•ra S. 3 i.. }y,`3 „'d �,� vu„�{ y+rc ai•, ,. �,rr,r! rt r •,.., .' :_ ..� �.. .a r � :;• ro f: �:., � :� �l� s",.e- $1....,,, t ��:f 1kx� qs - r':. vi.i� e.. ,,.. �„t 4 y -'Y ..,•. ,...,r. - c: ,,,�,: , s_ ,,. •... . .: :�: _-_ -+, ,. , r,,.�, s x �”, f e x v^iL `t� ..n�,t'"t,� '*•r,�.� ,.a.F -a a h,; ,r. t. .- ,.rf...,... ........ __. ,_ _.::: ,..., :-:� ,.,,.. ,r:,:,a a.,.... ,d -,a�'-� `Si ,�wu.'w. �rl„ rL -....,E;. � V o: •,. .,, f Y.'J! z S..y„ty�. -,��'` ... t .,..:. „ .,.:':,. ._ _. ,:.,.;: ��,,. +,M ,;r, -,.,� a..,:....:. ,.. ...x. � g... ,,� L uAt.' .V. 3+}�fa �y . ,,..� �,• >;•u.. t. 5.,:•e b .a,l° r ,d d:-�:.:..-, t,.=.., ......,. _ _ ... .�, .,.:1... t „ ,. ,.,,. w.. w,t F.l,.,,r.,, M1 .:.v .,ro 8.. � }P, r:k a+3:',: 4 r'�' ❑ �'t g� .',3=u:. u a p u' +:)i'^Y �.. .,, .:..... .:....: _.. - h... �, A.. w ... �:,,:•, v 4 ki.:.l r y..r:. ,,y �4,• �v�. .v�r#`h�v� .? ._,. :l.;R :y i,k ,:1::i - ,. ..F CN�..- �r .1,!' N `� 4<:,. r .... '.�,, .. _ n.:� „. .., k ,:A n��:,r.. 1 t Y k ��" .�.,. x Jk�:�' k r. ;+5" k '�•''? 3k z -r, h =.�,-�:.at..u.. ,�o � �.dY$ ..,r. .uw. m 'o r I r' suo�`., i3.. r..,F., a,•rf t a.i,� 2�5... A .......^ i Off-SITE SPILL AND GLARE i 80' Pole •AS FIXTURE MOUNTING HEIGHT IS REdUCEd, THE RESUITING IMPACT OF OFF,SITE AREAS INCREASES. u •AS FIXTURE MOUNTING HEIGHT IS R 38 EdUCEd, IiGHTING VISIbIIiTy FROM i A diSTANCE'IS GREATLY iNCREASEd. INCLUdING THe PROdUCTION OF 70' Pole UPWARdOS^Y GLOW t .........___.__._-...,!__..: ..._...............°_..........._......_......................._..............._...........----. •IN AddITION, AS FOIE HEIGHTS ARE REducEd THE RESUITIN(j 9UAI1TY OF IIgHTING ON tHE PIAy1Nq Fidd i5 AISO GREATIy REdUCEd �• =W, ' _ '_................60'Pole................ ....... POLE ROT .GLARE LIGW IMPACT @150' FROM FIELD ' 80' < .50 FoOTCANdIE5=230/0 APPROX.REdUCTION FROM dES1GN ,�', •' '�jO� 70' .65 FOOTCANdIES=OFF+SITE IMPACT AS dEs1GNEd 45 Pole 60' 1.00 FOOTCANdIES=54%APPROX.INCREASE ,' , •'' , 4F 1.45 FOOTCANdIES=123%APPROX.INCREASE � • ! ,'/ .240 ' i.;� ;, '• ' 2g' >$.00 FOOTCANdiE5=6709b APPROX.INCREASE 25' Pole Tkese va}UES AnE denived Ina■COMt)UTER NOdEIs PnEVIOUSIy PREPAREd j[1�4�•if(�` rr,. ANd bASEd ON VA"AQ POLE kE10TS. ' •�! I, r }{''��{�lf,/� Ell jgt},'FIS{ lt#'rt}K , Wig�Vr + �iY���tSR�✓ ti�af r}a� F !yrlt .i tyS'tNi r�sj Residence DISTANCE FROM ga p ; r lyTr4�ilr3} f i ����✓�r!�h 6r�f t, { 'POLE 5 J FIELD SfFBACK TO �Vir}��>f r�j44�FJ ltl8t'I L r RESIDENCE ; }ItJ� L �14�IT i I I TYP SOCCER FIELD - W No Scale Ln Evolution of Light 1989 2005 SportsCluster, SportsCluster,.2 SportsCluster-2 Total Light Light-Structure with Level 8 Control" Green' The Tom Barber Driving range, is utilizing the Level 8 technology available during the 1990's,the new proposed 70' poles would utilize the Light Structure Green Technology on the far right. V11. 36 mum 0 Golf Installations* Driving Ranges Par 3 Courses Abu Dhabi Golf Club Himlam Driving Range Beijing Moon River Golf Course Abu Dhabi,United Arab Emirates Ho Chi Minh,Vietnam Beijing,China Atkinson Country Club Imperial Golf Township 9 lighted holes Atkinson,New Hampshire Ludhiana,India Duran Golf Club Ascarate Golf Course Iowa State Universit Melbourne,Florida y 9 lighted holes El Paso,Texas Veenker Driving Range Driving range Balan Count Club Driving Range Ames,Iowa Country 9 9 Indio Golf Course Hwaseong,South Korea Prospect Driving Range Indio,California Beijing Taige Sports and Recreation Center Gorey,Ireland 18 lighted holes Beijing,China Sichuan Panzhihua Golf Driving Range Driving range Blue Island Driving Range Panzhihua,China Kimcheon Golf Land Par 3 Country Club Incheon,South Korea Sihui Nantian Golf Driving Range Kimcheon,South Korea Zhaoqing,China 9 lighted holes Bradford Creek Driving Range Greenville,North Carolina Stanley Golf Course Paju New Grand Prix Par 3 Country Club New Britain,Connecticut Paju,South Korea Carlsbad Golf Course 9 lighted holes Carlsbad,California Sugar Creek The Wave Golf Villa Tuscania Driving Range Villa Park,Illinois Muscat,Oman La Libertad,El Salvador The Els Club Driving Range 5 lighted holes Dubai Festival City Driving Range Dubai,United Arab Emirates Driving range Dubai,United Arab Emirates Tianfu Country Club Tianjin Green Golf Chengdu,China Tianjin,China Dulles Presidential Golf Course 9 lighted holes Dulles,Virginia TMV Golf Course Yas Island Golf Arouca,Trinidad and Tobago Falls Road Golf Course Abu Dhabi,United Arab Emirates Potomac,Maryland TopGolf Wood Dale Driving Range 6 lighted holes Florida A&M University Wood Dale,Illinois Driving range Tallahassee,Florida University of Washington Fort Sill Army Base Seattle,Washington Fort Sill,Oklahoma Uptown Cairo Golf Galloping Hills Cairo,Egypt p g Chipping Area Kenilworth,New Jersey Glen Cove Golf Valley Golf Center Avondale,Arizona Glen Cove,New York Golf Academy Yellow Bamboo Golf y Bangkok,Thailand New Delhi,India Goseong Nobel Country Club Driving Range Goseong,South Korea Viii. 'Partial Listing ©2002,2011 Musco Sports Lighting,LLC PR-0065-2 37 EAPORT OIGHTING INC . June 26, 2012 Mr. Dave Bobardt City of Moorpark 799 Moorpark Ave Moorpark, CA 93021 Mr. Joe Vacca City of Moorpark 799 Moorpark Ave Moorpark, CA 93021 Subject: Tom Barber Golf Center—Driving Range Lighting review Dear Mr.Bobardt and Mr. Vacca: After careful review of all supporting documents provided concerning the newly proposed Musco lighting system for the Golf Center, I acknowledge this is an acceptable lighting strategy to implement. Of note, however, the photometric grid calculation overlay terminates at the property line so the actual spill-over cannot be determined. I do believe the spill over to be nominal beyond 60' as the light levels depicted on the 30' x 30' grid drop substantially at every grid point beyond a specific concentrated light source. Given the optical design of the proposed fixture along with the fixture height specified and fixturelpole locations, I believe this overall solution to be the best option available for this type of night-time business. The optical assembly should provide ample task illumination while minimizing sky glow and glare to passers-by. Please let me know if I can provide further assistance. Sincerely, Teri L Jackson, LC, MIES Cell: 760-969-8348 Office: 760-730-5906 Fax: 866-268-2547 Email: terij @seaportlighting.com P.O. BOX 1639, OCEANSIDE, CA 92051 622 S. FREEMAN ST.,OCEANSIDE, CA 92054 CC ATTACHMENT 2 38